Football

Player Ratings as Scotland Lose 2-0 to Peru

Player Ratings as Scotland Lose 2-0 to Peru

Scotland lost 2-0 to Peru in the early hours of this morning.

But the result isn’t the most important thing to come of the match – it was the performance of many new boys as well as some experienced players who made up Alex McLeish’s team.

The Tartan Army manager handed debuts to seven players in the game, with Jordan Archer, Stephen O’Donnell, Lewis Stevenson, Dylan McGeouch, Chris Cadden, Graeme Shinnie and Lewis Morgan all getting their first caps.

So how did they do? Here are our player ratings for the game:

Jordan Archer – 5

Embed from Getty Images

There’s been significant clamour for Archer to be given the number one jersey for Scotland after his emergence as Millwall’s first choice goalkeeper, but he did nothing tonight to support that. He made mistakes for both goals and they ultimately killed Scotland.

Stephen O’Donnell – 7

Embed from Getty Images

O’Donnell definitely didn’t look out of place on his debut. The Kilmarnock man was rewarded with a start after a fine season under Steve Clarke and he played like a man high on confidence. Considering Scotland’s lack of quality right backs, O’Donnell could find himself in future squads after that.

Charlie Mulgrew – 6

Embed from Getty Images

It was much of the same from Mulgrew, who captained the team tonight. McLeish knows what he’s getting from the Blackburn defender and nothing against Peru will have changed his mind.

Scott McKenna – 6

Embed from Getty Images

McKenna wasn’t as impressive against Peru as he was against Costa Rica and Hungary, but he didn’t do much wrong either. His handball did lead to the penalty opener for the South Americans, but that was more down to Archer’s mistake than his handball. Expect McKenna to continue at centre half going forward.

Lewis Stevenson – 6

Embed from Getty Images

Stevenson played like a man who knows this is probably his only Scotland squad call-up. When Kieran Tierney, Andy Robertson and Barry Douglas are back available, he’ll be back to spending international weeks in Edinburgh, but he made the most of this opportunity. Despite the occasional threat on the Peru right, Stevenson actually spent more time going forward and looked good doing it.

Dylan McGeouch – 7

Embed from Getty Images

McGeouch was definitely deserving of his start after playing so well for Hibs this season – and he proved that with a sound performance. He’s the only Scotland midfielder capable of dictating play despite it not always coming off in Lima. There’s a big case to be made for McLeish sculpting his midfield around the deep playmaking of the former Hibs man.

Kenny McLean – 6

Embed from Getty Images

It was always going to be difficult for McLean with him lining up on the right of the midfield. He’s an attacking midfielder and has done most of his good work over recent years playing through the centre, but he coped well and looked better late in the game when McLeish moved him in one. Nothing sensational, but nothing too bad either.

Scott McTominay – 6

Embed from Getty Images

That’s McTominay’s second game for Scotland and we’re still none the wiser about what sort of player he’s going to be for the national team. He’s box to box, simple and effective for Manchester United, but more is expected of him for Scotland – and he didn’t show that last night. Hopefully McLeish can find the right place for him before any competitive qualifiers kick off.

Next page for more ratings

Pages: 1 2

Football

More in Football

Craig Levein Jokes He’ll Bid for Alfredo Morelos Ahead of Rangers Showdown

Daniel CawOctober 16, 2019

Christopher Jullien Apologises to Celtic Fans and Says Livingston Slip-up ‘Won’t Happen Again’

Daniel CawOctober 16, 2019

Video: Arsenal Youngster Eddie Nketiah Bangs Home Hat-Trick for England U21s

Daniel CawOctober 15, 2019

Video: Odsonne Edouard Scores Another Brace to Make it 8 in 4 for France Under-21s

Daniel CawOctober 15, 2019

Video: Dundee’s First-Team Takes on 100 School Kids at Dens Park and Lose 14-1

Daniel CawOctober 15, 2019

5 of Robert Snodgrass’ Best Scotland Goals As He Announces Retirement

Daniel CawOctober 15, 2019

Video: Marcus Rashford Scores Peach of a Goal for England Against Bulgaria

Daniel CawOctober 14, 2019

Steve Clarke Praises ‘Character and Resilience’ of His Scotland Players After San Marino Win

Daniel CawOctober 13, 2019

Video: Rangers Midfielder Joe Aribo Scores for Nigeria Against Brazil

Daniel CawOctober 13, 2019