Why David Moyes Isn’t the Right Man to Become Permanent Celtic Boss

Why David Moyes Isn’t the Right Man to Become Permanent Celtic Boss

David Moyes is now the bookies’ favourite to become the next Celtic manager.

The former Everton and Manchester United boss has been linked with the job ever since Brendan Rodgers left for Leicester City in February.

But it’s taken a while for him to become favourite to get the role, with Neil Lennon, Rafa Benitez and Jose Mourinho all enjoying a spell at the top of the bookies’ odds.

Now, though, Moyes is as low as 2/5 with some bookmakers – and listed at 6/4 with SPFL sponsors Ladbrokes.

And that’s led to plenty of online discussion among supporters about whether or not he’s the right man for the job.

Here, we lay out why we believe he’s not:

1 – His Recent Track Record

Embed from Getty Images

There’s no denying Moyes did an outstanding job over 11 years at Everton – but he left that job six years ago now. Since then, he had a torrid 10 months at United, one poor year at Real Sociedad, an awful 10 months at Sunderland and just seven months at West Ham. He even had a relegation in that spell with Sunderland. He’s been out of work over a year now and you have to think there’s a reason for that.

2 – No Upgrade on Neil Lennon

Embed from Getty Images

Is he better than Lennon? We don’t think so. Lennon has his faults as Celtic manager, but he’s led them to six major trophies and is likely to get a seventh this weekend. Surely the only way Lennon doesn’t get the job is if there’s an outstanding alternative candidate who is available?

3 – Celtic May Be a Stop Gap to Him

Embed from Getty Images

How long until Moyes swaps Celtic for an English team in a similar way to Rodgers? That didn’t end well for the Northern Irishman or the club and the board must be weary of that happening again – regardless of any Moyes success.

4 – Different Style to Brendan Rodgers

Embed from Getty Images

Say what you like about Rodgers’ character and the controversial way he left Celtic mid-season, but there’s no denying he put out a quality Celtic team on to the park. Standards were raised at the Hoops by Rodgers playing an attractive, attacking style – something Moyes wasn’t renowned for at Everton or any other job since then. Given the players and the coaching staff in place, surely a manager with a similar playing philosophy to Rodgers would suit Celtic best?

5 – Has Won Just One Trophy

Embed from Getty Images

Moyes’ only trophy success came in 2000 when he led Preston to the English Second Division title (League One now). Since then, he’s won absolutely nothing major with any team he’s been in charge of.

6 – There Are Better Options

Embed from Getty Images

Benitez, Mourinho, Andre Villas Boas, Slaven Bilic and Lennon – they must all be considered better options than Moyes?

7 – His Spanish

That doesn’t really count. Just any excuse to use it again.


More in Football

6 Best Youth Football Academies with Historical Roots That Have Managed to Pass the Test of Time

Jonny BoyleNovember 26, 2020

Jamie Young’s Journey To The Top

Jonny BoyleNovember 18, 2020

Why AC Milan Visit is a Significant Point in Celtic’s Season

Jonny BoyleOctober 22, 2020

Why Scotland Has a Chance of Best Representation in Europe For Years

Jonny BoyleSeptember 24, 2020

Are Chelsea Now Title Contenders With New Signings?

Jonny BoyleSeptember 10, 2020

Why We Should All Be Excited About Leeds United’s Premier League Return

Jonny BoyleSeptember 8, 2020

Serie A: Gian Piero Gasperini Has Turned Atalanta into One of the Most Entertaining Sides in Europe

Jonny BoyleAugust 19, 2020

Remembering the Underrated Genius of Diego Milito

Jonny BoyleAugust 17, 2020

Why Rangers Have to Take Advantage of Celtic Lay-Off

Jonny BoyleAugust 13, 2020